Keith McCarthy

Keith McCarthy

Senior Editor

I am an experienced sports analyst with a lifetime of sports knowledge and expertise. I combine a unique mix of statistical analysis, the “eye-test”, and pure gut feeling to predict sports outcomes at a tremendous success rate.

I have predicted the outcome of top events down to the very point. My aim is to share my analysis with others in an attempt to expand the public wealth of knowledge when it comes to finding winning bets at a consistent rate. I only predict games that I feel confident in.

I am fascinated by sports statistics and the variety of different ways to analyze all aspects of the sport, from teams to players to coaches. I love to analyze these statistics and utilize them to make even more accurate picks than before.

Using my vast knowledge and experience, I will provide you with unbeatable coverage that is succinct, informative, and very accurate. My expertise is in college sports and the professional “big four” though I have a catalog of experience in every sports category.

Favorites

  • Go-To Betting Markets
  • BetOnline, BetUS, Bovada
  • Favorite Bets:
  • Large spread underdogs, Mahomes in the NFL playoffs, home team parlays
  • Favorite Team:
  • Knicks, Giants
  • Favorite Sport:
  • Basketball, Football
  • Industry Experience:
  • 3+ years of sports writing and analysis, 5+ years of sports betting, 10+ years of fantasy sports experience, 20+ years of sports viewership.
  • Expertise:
  • NFL, NBA, NHL, MLB, WNBA, NCAAF, NCAAM, NCAAW, PGA

Biggest Win: Exact Score Bet; $5 -> $1,000

Best Betting Moment: Winning back-to-back fantasy titles in football and basketball

Worst Beat: Giants to make Super Bowl in 2024, $20 -> $0

Latest Picks by Keith McCarthy

New England Patriots vs Las Vegas Raiders

09/07/2025 1:01 PM ET

PICK – Spread:

New England Patriots -3.0

Best Odds

betonline.ag

-3 -123
betus

-3 -115

 everygame

-3 -115

 betanysports

-3 -115

The Raiders and Patriots clash in Week 1. New England is hoping to take a step forward as Drake Maye continues to progress, while the Raiders added superstar Ashton Jeanty to the mix.

Keith McCarthy – Pick Made 4 days ago Read Full Analysis

Indianapolis Colts vs Miami Dolphins

09/07/2025 1:01 PM ET

PICK – Spread:

Indianapolis Colts -1.5

Best Odds

betonline.ag

-1.5 -115
betus

-1.5 -105

 everygame

-1.5 -110

 betanysports

-1.5 -110

The Dolphins face off with the Colts in their opener. Seeking to avoid another letdown, Miami will lean on their talented offense to attempt to overwhelm Daniel Jones and Indianapolis.

Keith McCarthy – Pick Made 4 days ago Read Full Analysis

South Carolina Gamecocks vs Virginia Tech Hokies

08/31/2025 3:00 PM ET

PICK – Spread:

South Carolina -8.0

Best Odds

betonline.ag

-8 -110
betus

-8 -115

 everygame

-8 -110

 betanysports

-8 -110

 lowvig.ag

-8 -106

South Carolina and Virginia Tech face off in an SEC/ACC battle in Atlanta. The Gamecocks are hoping to crack the CFP this season, and need to start the year with a win over the scrappy Hokies.

Keith McCarthy – Pick Made 6 days ago Read Full Analysis

Florida State Seminoles vs Alabama Crimson Tide

08/30/2025 3:30 PM ET

PICK – Spread:

Alabama Crimson Tide -13.5

Best Odds

betonline.ag

-13.5 -118
betus

-13.5 -115

 everygame

-13.5 -110

 betanysports

-13.5 -110

 lowvig.ag

-13.5 -114

Alabama is looking to bounce back after missing the CFP last season. They'll face a Florida State team that is seeking a redemption tour of their own after a wildly disappointing season.

Keith McCarthy – Pick Made 6 days ago Read Full Analysis

Syracuse Orange vs Tennessee Volunteers

08/30/2025 2:00 PM ET

PICK – Spread:

Syracuse Orange +14.5

Best Odds

betonline.ag

+14.5 -110
betus

+14.5 -110

 everygame

+14.5 -110

 betanysports

+14.5 -110

 lowvig.ag

+14.5 -106

Syracuse and Tennessee meet in their opener in a battle of orange-colored teams. The Volunteers narrowly stayed inside the top-25 and will aim to prove themselves against Syracuse.

Keith McCarthy – Pick Made 6 days ago Read Full Analysis

Miami Hurricanes vs Notre Dame Fighting Irish

08/31/2025 7:30 PM ET

PICK – Spread:

Notre Dame -2.5

Best Odds

betonline.ag

-2.5 -115
betus

-2.5 -110

 everygame

-2.5 -110

 betanysports

-2.5 -110

 lowvig.ag

-2 -111

The defending runners-up head to #10 Miami in their 2025 opener. Notre Dame enters with a slight edge against a Hurricanes team that no longer has phenom QB Cam Ward.

Keith McCarthy – Pick Made 2 weeks ago Read Full Analysis

Latest Articles by Keith McCarthy