MLS: New York City vs. Columbus Picks — Crew to Close in on Playoff Spot? (Sep 17)

A rare round of midweek matches is set for the MLS this week, and a fascinating clash with implications on the playoff spots is set. You can find our New York City vs. Columbus picks here.

New York bounced back to winning ways in their latest outing, as they recorded a 3-1 success over Chicago. That win leaves them sitting seventh in the standings, and within touching distance of securing their spot in the post-season.

Columbus come into the round sitting fifth in the Eastern Conference standings, having won 13 of their 29 matches in 2025. Two wins could be enough to secure their spot in the playoffs.  

New York City vs. Columbus Overview

Odds

New York City vs. Columbus Head-to-Head Record

Two of the last three meetings between New York City and Columbus have ended in draws. That includes a 0-0 stalemate earlier this season.

New York City Team News

It’s likely that NYC will field an unchanged eleven following an excellent 3-1 success over Chicago in the previous round of fixtures.

Possible Lineup

Freese (GK); Gray, Martins, Gustavo, O’Toole; O’Neill, Haak; Wolf, Moralez, Fernandez; Martinez

Columbus Team News

Diego Rossi has been ruled out for up to a month after netting a hat-trick in the 5-4 success against Atlanta United on Saturday. Ibrahim Aliyu could replace the star man.

Possible Lineup

Schulte (GK); Amundsen, Cheberko, Moreira, Herrera; Gazdag, Chambost, Nagbe, Arfsten; Aliyu, Ali

New York City vs. Columbus Picks

Rossi’s absence is a massive blow for the Crew this week, and it will be detrimental to their chances in the offensive areas. Due to that, this could be a perfect opportunity for the hosts to maintain their playoff push. A home win is preferred when making New York City vs. Columbus picks.