Cavaliers vs Pacers Game 5 NBA Player Prop Picks (May 13)

• The Pacers dominated Game 4 with a 129–109 victory.
• The Cavaliers struggled in Game 4, with Donovan Mitchell exiting early due to injury and the team trailing by as much as 41 points.
• These two teams last met on May 11, the Pacers won 129–109, taking a 3–1 series lead.

The Cleveland Cavaliers host the Indiana Pacers in Game 5 of the Eastern Conference Semifinals on Tuesday, May 13, at Rocket Arena. Tip-off is scheduled for 7:00 p.m. ET, with live coverage on TNT.

Cleveland Cavaliers Player Prop Pick: Darius Garland

Facing elimination, the Cavaliers return home trailing 3–1 in the series. Donovan Mitchell’s status remains uncertain after exiting Game 4 with a non-contact ankle injury. Despite the setback, Mitchell remains optimistic about playing in Game 5. Darius Garland led the team with 21 points in Game 4, but the Cavaliers will need a collective effort to extend the series.

Cleveland’s resilience will be tested as they aim to overcome injuries and regain momentum in this critical matchup.

• With Donovan Mitchell’s status uncertain, Garland is expected to shoulder more of the scoring load.
• Garland led the Cavaliers with 21 points in Game 4, demonstrating his ability to step up when needed.
• Playing at home, Garland may benefit from familiar surroundings and crowd support to boost his performance.

Indiana Pacers Player Prop Pick: Andrew Nembhard

The Pacers have taken a commanding 3–1 series lead, showcasing their depth and offensive efficiency. Pascal Siakam led the team with 21 points in Game 4, while Myles Turner and Obi Toppin contributed 20 points each. Indiana’s ability to capitalize on Cleveland’s injuries has been a significant factor in their success.

Indiana aims to close out the series with another strong performance, relying on their balanced attack and defensive prowess.

• Nembhard has been a reliable presence, contributing across multiple statistical categories.
• With Cleveland’s injuries, Nembhard has opportunities to impact the game through rebounds and assists.
• Indiana’s balanced offense allows Nembhard to find teammates effectively, increasing his assist potential.