Rangers vs. Maple Leafs NHL Picks: Travelling Rangers Chasing Return to Form (Oct 16)

Published Oct 15, 3:55am EDT by

Alex Dudley - Betting Preview Analyst and Sports Writer

Last updated Oct 15, 3:55am EDT

Pick status
NHL action is set for Madison Square Garden on Dec 7. Find the latest NHL odds and our Golden Knights vs. Rangers Picks here.

Credit: Shutterstock

Updated Oct 15, 3:55am EDT

  • New York Rangers have gone 2-3-0 at the start of the 2025-26 NHL season
  • Toronto Maple Leafs have won two of their opening four games

The competitive action in the NHL continues on Oct 16, as the Scotiabank Arena hosts a showdown between the Toronto Maple Leafs and the New York Rangers.

The Rangers have had a below-par start to the campaign, suffering defeats in three of their first five games.

Meanwhile, the Maple Leafs will be chasing consistency after winning just half of their opening four games. You can find our Rangers vs. Maple Leafs picks here.

Toronto Maple Leafs vs. New York Rangers Overview Watch On: ESPN+

DATE & TIME

Thursday, October 16, 2025 @ 7:00 PM ET
Toronto Maple Leafs
Scotiabank Arena, Toronto
New York Rangers
GAME ODDS
BetOnline
Toronto Maple Leafs TBA
New York Rangers TBA

Maple Leafs Hoping to Build Consistency

Craig Berube's Toronto Maple Leafs are still seeking to establish consistency in the NHL this season.

Toronto come into this round after winning two of their four games this term. Meanwhile, they have already suffered two regulation-time losses in the first week.

However, Toronto's confidence would have improved on Tuesday after scoring seven goals in a win over the Nashville Predators. Unsurprisingly, Auston Matthews was the standout star in the victory, netting twice from five shots.

Struggling Rangers Aiming for Win Streak

Based on the first week of the season, the New York Rangers appear to be miles off the pace in the race for a playoff spot in 2025-26.

The Rangers have already suffered three defeats in regulation time this term, and they have registered just two wins. A sign of their issues was reflected in their recent 2-0 loss against the Edmonton Oilers.

The Rangers struggled in the offensive areas of the field, and that will need to change if they are to mount a serious playoff challenge in 2025-26.

Rangers vs. Maple Leafs NHL Picks

It hasn't been the start to the season that either of these teams would have been hoping for. Therefore, there will be pressure on both the Maple Leafs and the Rangers on Thursday.

However, it could be challenging to overlook the home win when making Rangers vs. Maple Leafs picks based on Toronto's strong attacking display against Nashville on Tuesday.

Pick
Toronto Maple Leafs
New Player Bonus
50% up to $1000