Penguins vs. Maple Leafs NHL Picks: Toronto Bottom of Atlantic Division (Dec 23)

Published Dec 22, 3:55am ET by

Alex Dudley - Betting Preview Analyst and Sports Writer

Last updated Dec 22, 3:55am ET

Pick status
NHL action is set for Scotiabank Arena on Dec 23. Find the latest NHL odds and our Penguins vs. Maple Leafs picks here.

Credit: Shutterstock

Updated Dec 22, 3:55am ET

  • Toronto Maple Leafs have dropped to the foot of the Atlantic Division after losing their last three
  • Pittsburgh Penguins have gone 2-4-4 over their last ten

Two sides in disappointing recent form will collide in the NHL on Dec 23, as the Toronto Maple Leafs host the Pittsburgh Penguins. Find our picks here.

Toronto have dropped to the bottom of the Atlantic Division after losing each of their last three. Therefore, they now have an overall record of 15-15-5 this season.

The Penguins also sit toward the foot of the Metropolitan Division after losing eight of their last ten. Their overall record in the NHL this season now stands at 15-11-9.

Toronto Maple Leafs vs. Pittsburgh Penguins Overview Watch On: ESPN+

DATE & TIME

Tuesday, December 22, 2025 @ 4:00 PM ET
Toronto Maple Leafs
Scotiabank Arena, Toronto
Pittsburgh Penguins

Maple Leafs in Desperate Need of a Win

The 2025-26 season has been a huge disappointment for the Toronto Maple Leafs to this point, and their playoff aspirations already appear to be hanging by a thread.

Toronto sit bottom of the Atlantic Division, and they have gone 4-4-2 over their last ten. Meanwhile, they have suffered defeats in each of their previous three.

Toronto’s most recent loss was suffered in Dallas on Sunday, as they were heavily beaten 5-1 by the Stars. A much better performance at both ends of the ice will be required on Tuesday.

ALSO SEE: FIFA World Cup Draw, Latest Odds, and Early Picks (2026)

Penguins In Poor Recent Form

There will also be pressure on the Penguins this week, as they sit second bottom in the Metropolitan Division, despite boasting a positive overall record.

Pittsburgh have gone 15-11-9 this season, but their dip in form has seen them go 2-4-4 over their last ten.

However, confidence would have been gained in their latest outing after registering a 4-3 shootout success against the Montreal Canadiens. Rickard Rakell and Sidney Crosby both scored goals in the hard-fought win.

Penguins vs. Maple Leafs Head-to-Head Record
TOTAL Penguins Maple Leafs DRAWS
WINS 214 96 101 -
GOALS 1474 732 742

Penguins vs. Maple Leafs Picks

Confidence will be low among both teams, and that will make this game challenging to call. However, home advantage could be crucial factor. Toronto have won just under 53% of their home games against the Penguins.

Pick
Toronto Maple Leafs
New Player Bonus
50% up to $1000