Creighton vs Seton Hall NCAAB Pick: Bluejays look to advance in Big East Tournament (Mar 12)

Published Mar 12, 12:48am ET by

Gabriel Kozlow - Betting Preview Analyst and Sports Writer

Last updated Mar 12, 12:48am ET

Pick status
Euroleague: Baskonia vs. Partizan Preview, prediction, H2H

Shutterstock

Updated Mar 12, 12:48am ET

  • Creighton (15-16) beat Butler 76-59 to end their 3-game losing streak.
  • Seton Hall (OH) (20-11) lost 65-72 to St. Johns for their 3rd loss in 5 games.
  • The all-time record between these teams has Creighton with a leading 19-10 record.

We have a Big East Conference Quarterfinal matchup between the Creighton Bluejays and the Seton Hall Pirates at Madison Square Garden. Both teams have solid chances to improve their March Madness odds, as a win here would strengthen their tournament hopes.

SETON HALL PIRATES vs. CREIGHTON BLUEJAYS Overview Watch On: PEACOCK

DATE & TIME

THURSDAY, MARCH 11, 2026 @1:30 PM ET
SETON HALL PIRATES
Madison Square Garden
New York, NY
CREIGHTON BLUEJAYS
GAME ODDS
BetOnline
SETON HALL PIRATES -2.5 (-105)
CREIGHTON BLUEJAYS +2.5 (-105)

Bluejays to Rely on Elite Offense

The Creighton Bluejays has had a mediocre season so far and will need to make a run in the tournament if they want to improve their March Madness odds. They enter the game as slight underdogs and will need their offense to get the job done.

For More March Madness Betting Odds and Predictions, See the Full Hub

The team’s top scorer is Josh Dix, averaging 12.7 PPG while shooting 43% from the field. The Bluejays will need to perform better offensively and shoot higher than their current 45% team field goal percentage if they want to win. Nik Graves, their primary playmaker, will also need to step up.

Pirates Count on Defense to get Job Done

Seton Hall ended the regular season with a respectable 20-11 overall record, but a mediocre 10-10 mark in conference play. The Pirates have better March Madness odds than their rivals, but they still need to advance to the next round. They started the season 11-1 but began to decline as the season went on.

Adam Clark is usually their first option on offense, but defense is where they truly shine. Seton Hall currently ranks 8th in points allowed, giving up just 65.1 PPG. Much of that is thanks to Najai Hines protecting the paint and Clark defending the perimeter.

Creighton versus Seton Hall NCAAB Pick

The game is expected to be intense, as the Pirates are favored by just -2.5 on the spread. The over/under is 133.5, with the moneyline set at -155 for Seton Hall and +130 for Creighton.

We feel that the lack of offensive options for the Bluejays will not be enough to overcome the Pirates’ defense. Our take favors the Seton Hall Pirates -2.5.

Pick
Seton Hall Pirates -2.5
New Player Bonus
50% up to $1000