Yankees vs Red Sox MLB Player Prop Picks (Jun 13)

First pitch is at 7:10 p.m. ET at Fenway Park. The Red Sox (34–36) enter as modest favorites at home against the Yankees (41–25), marking the first time the rivals meet this season. Tonight’s duel features a lefty showdown between Boston ace Garrett Crochet and New York’s crafty Ryan Yarbrough, setting the stage for a classic AL East confrontation.

• Boston has claimed 4 of their last 5 games, with Crochet establishing himself as a top-tier lefty, second in MLB in strikeouts (110) and boasting a 2.35 ERA.
• New York holds a 41–25 record, anchored by power hitting (.468 SLG) and elite offense (5.5 R/G, second in MLB).
• Pitching Matchup: Crochet (6–4, 2.35 ERA, 110 K) faces Yarbrough (3–1, 4.17 ERA, 1.15 WHIP)—a contrast of dominant strikeout ability vs. efficient contact management.

New York Yankees Player Prop Pick: Aaron Judge

The Yankees remain atop the division thanks to a dominant power-based offense fueled by Aaron Judge (25 HR, .392 AVG) and Paul Goldschmidt, backed by dependable pitching depth featuring Max Fried and closer Devin Williams. Though lacking a true No. 1 starter, their lineup continues to force high run production every night.

• Power Streak: Judge has 25 HR in 67 games and has homered in three straight; his slugging and power put him in great position.
• Fenway Factor: Even as an away player, Judge’s power translates in smaller parks and he’s in prime home run form.
• Previous Performance: Launched consecutive homers in recent matchups—timing is spot-on.

Boston Red Sox Player Prop Pick: Garrett Crochet

Boston is gaining ground in the AL East behind Garrett Crochet, whose high strikeout rate, control, and innings load are bolstering a recently ineffective roster. With stars like Rafael Devers (14 HR, .276/.345/.500) and emerging talents like Marcelo Mayer, Boston is clawing back toward contention. Their pitching depth, led by Crochet and a top-10 bullpen, is now the offense’s foundation.

• Strikeout Leader: Crochet ranks 2nd in MLB with 110 strikeouts over 88 innings—expectation is 8+ K against the Yankees.
• Previous vs. Yankees: He subdued their potent lineup last weekend in New York, earning two of Boston’s wins.
• Matchup Advantage: With a sub-1.10 WHIP and dominant strikeout-style, he profiles for high-K outings.