Blue Jays vs Guardians MLB Player Prop Picks (Jun 25)

Toronto Blue Jays (42–36) look to regain control after winning Game 1 of this three-game series. They face off against the Cleveland Guardians (39–38), who rebounded offensively in Game 1. The total is set around 8.5 runs in a balanced matchup featuring veteran and rising pitching depth.

• Blue Jays lead the season series 2–2 after a 10–6 win in Game 1 behind a grand slam from George Springer and a solid outing from Eric Lauer.
• Toronto’s Max Scherzer (0–0, 6.00 ERA, limited early-season action) vs. Cleveland’s Gavin Williams (5–3, 3.58 ERA, 78 K)
• Guardians struggle with strikeouts (11th-most in MLB at 8.6 K/9), while Blue Jays hit .257 and slug .401 vs. RHP.

Toronto Blue Jays Player Prop Pick: Max Scherzer

Toronto features balanced offense with power threats in Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette, and veteran aces emerging in the rotation. Scherzer returns after IL placement, while the bullpen continues to stabilize. Their smart lineup matches up well with control pitchers.

• Scherzer has allowed 2 R in his only 3 IP appearance this season, keeping ERA steady.
• Guardians hit .230 and slug .372 overall, limiting high run games.
• His veteran command and efficient innings offer a safe floor.

Cleveland Guardians Player Prop Pick: Gavin Williams

Cleveland relies on Gavin Williams’ depth and control. The offense generates contact and situational hitting, though lacks high-end power. Guardians are consistent at home (19–16) and have out-hit teams when reaching 8+ hits in a game.

• Williams averages 9.3 K/9 with 78 K in 75⅓ IP, showing strong whiff upside.
• Blue Jays strike out frequently vs. RHP, ranking top half of MLB.
• He logs 5+ innings consistently, providing enough volume for 6+ Ks.