Best Premier League Betting Sites

Premier League Prop Bets
Although the overall outcome of a game can be too unpredictable to call, soccer fans can often be sure about specific aspects of a team’s or an individual’s performance. 

BetOnline stands out against the competition due to its prop builder. We found it allowed us to quickly scan the available markets and build a prop parlay in seconds, with hundreds of markets available for each game.

Premier League Player Prop Bets
This is where we found BetOnline’s market depth really allowed our soccer knowledge to shine. Player markets like number of passes, tackles, and shots allow you to take advantage of a game’s flow.

Much like the team props, there are 100s of individual markets to be found, meaning every aspect of the game can be wagered on.

Premier League Totals bets
Betting on goal totals in a game is often looked at as one of the “bare minimum” standards when assessing a sportsbook, so it’s the least we would expect from the best betting site for the Premier League.

BetOnline still goes beyond the basic 2.5 goals line, however, with markets available for each half, and the prop betting markets allow you to go deeper into totals betting by choosing your own total, or picking totals for an individual team rather than the game.

Premier League Outright Betting
Although “outright” betting usually relates to the futures market for the Premier League winner, we do look out for other futures markets.

Of course, BetOnline offered odds on the overall Premier League winner, but they also offered futures markets on teams to be relegated or to qualify for the UCL.

This means they cover the entire table rather than focusing on the first-placed team, and opens up additional value for soccer bettors.

Premier League Handicap Betting
Handicap betting is particularly popular in games with a clear favorite. There are similar aspects to spread betting where a handicap is applied to the favorite, and we found that BetOnline did offer these in their Premier League lines.

They also take into account the nuances of soccer draws to offer “3-way handicap” markets that include a draw as an option and increase the odds, helping them stand out against the competition on our list.

Premier League Prop Bets
Although BetUS does have prop betting in terms of overall game props and player props, they fall short of BetOnline’s standard for two reasons.

Firstly, the overall market volume is lower, and the layout also requires a lot of scrolling, rather than allowing us to see and access all markets from one place.

Premier League Over/Under Bets
The over/under markets allowed BetUS to bounce back immediately compared to other sportsbooks, as it has everything we wanted to see.

They go beyond the standard 2.5 total goals and also present alternative totals in the same space, allowing us to quickly compare the odds to see where the value lies.

Premier League Outright Betting
Although all of the expected EPL outright markets are present on BetUS, they can be hard to find for new users.

Instead of presenting Premier League game betting and futures betting in the same space, you need to scroll down to the bottom of the soccer section to find the outrights.

Premier League Handicap Betting
BetUS does offer handicap bets on English Premier League games, but unlike BetOnline, they don’t offer 3-way odds, which reduces the market options and potential value for bettors.

They are also found in the “ALT1” and “ALT2” sections of the game betting, which may not be immediately obvious to new players, and this furthered our view that, to become the best Premier League betting website, they need to improve the site’s navigation.

Prop Betting
Although they don’t have the same prop builder that allows BetOnline to outshine their competitors in Premier League betting, Lucky Rebel runs them close.

They have everything we wanted to see in terms of game and player props, with deep markets and a variety of options, and it’s well presented for easy navigation.

We also found it simple to mix game and player props together, and found a failsafe that wouldn’t allow us to compile a parlay of contradictory picks – for example, choosing under 2.5 game cards alongside 3 or more individual players to be booked.

Totals Bets
Adding to their status as a strong English Premier League sportsbook, Lucky Rebel has deep options for totals betting.

They also go beyond the usual over/under line of 2.5, with a variety of game markets and individual team markets.

For the game we tested, they had totals between 1.5 and 3.5, and between 1 and 2 for each team.
This is also well-presented, allowing easy odds comparisons and helping Premier League bettors find the extra edge.

Outright Betting
Although there was a Premier League futures section, we couldn’t find any active markets on Lucky Rebel at the time of our testing. It’s a growing sportsbook, and we expect to see multiple markets at the start of the 26/27 season.

Handicap Betting
Lucky Rebel does have Premier League handicap betting lines; however, they’re listed under “alternative spread”. This does the same thing as handicap betting, but we couldn’t find the 3-way options present on BetOnline.

Prop Betting
MyBookie may have the widest variety of Premier League prop betting options on the market, but it also comes with the downside of being tough to navigate.

There is no prop builder; instead, the list of markets on every game is crammed onto one page, so there’s a lot of scrolling involved, and there’s no rhyme or reason to the layout.

Despite this, if you can find what you’re looking for, the variety of odds on offer is impressive.

Over/Under Bet
Like the other sportsbooks on this page, MyBookie does a solid job of going beyond the standard 2.5 goal line. They have alternative totals options for both teams and individually, allowing you to find the best possible value for your wager.

Premier League Futures
Similar to Lucky Rebel, we could find a futures section and named markets for Premier League outright betting, but they weren’t active during our testing.

Handicap Betting
MyBookie’s handicap bets for the Premier League are listed under “Alternate-Handicap” beneath the game betting section, but it only had two options (0.5, 1.5) on the game we compared throughout the sportsbooks on our list.

Premier League Props/Player Props
Interestingly, we did find an extensive range of prop betting for Premier League games, and the layout looked similar to an earlier build of BetOnline’s prop builder before their recent updates.

Naturally, this means they don’t completely compare to the top Premier League sportsbook option, but the builder is easy to use, has extensive odds, and builds a prop parlay with ease.

Premier League Totals Bets
Totals betting is where all of our Premier League sportsbooks are completely aligned, with BetAnything completing a clean sweep across all five sites.

They also go beyond the 2.5 goal line, offering a variety of options for the game, each half, and each individual team.

Premier League Outrights
Unfortunately, there were no Premier League outrights betting options on BetAnything during our testing.

Handicap Betting
We also couldn’t find any handicap betting odds during our testing.