- The Toronto Blue Jays and Philadelphia Phillies meet Saturday at Citizens Bank Park.
- Max Scherzer takes the mound for Toronto.
- Aaron Nola gets the start for Philadelphia.
The Toronto Blue Jays visit Citizens Bank Park Saturday, and a red-hot Max Scherzer complicates the case for home favorite Aaron Nola and the Phillies.
Scherzer’s Season Has Been Brutal, but He’s Turned It Around
Max Scherzer carries a 7.92 ERA and 7.03 FIP this season, among the league’s worst lines. But his last three outings tell a different story, a 4.90 FIP more than two runs better than his season mark. That’s the largest recent-form swing on this week’s board, a genuine three-start stretch, not one clean outing. Toronto isn’t getting the pitcher his season line describes right now.
Toronto’s .678 team OPS trails Philadelphia’s by 31 points, the biggest structural gap in this matchup and the main reason the Phillies are favored. The Blue Jays do have the better recent form at 6-4 over their last ten against Philadelphia’s 5-5. Their bullpen sits at a 3.71 FIP, close to Philadelphia’s 3.60, but strikes out batters at a lower rate, 20.9% against 27.6%. None of that changes the core issue: Toronto doesn’t hit enough to lean on.
Nola’s Season Has Been Poor, and He’s Trending the Wrong Way
Aaron Nola has a 5.55 ERA and 5.22 FIP, also rough, though a full run better than Scherzer’s FIP. The problem is direction, not level: his last three starts have slipped to a 6.50 FIP, worse than his season mark and moving opposite his counterpart. Backing Nola over Scherzer means trusting the fuller season sample, since the recent trend favors Toronto right now.
Philadelphia’s .709 team OPS is the best offensive number in this game, and the bullpen backs it with a 27.6% strikeout rate, 6.7 points above Toronto’s despite nearly identical FIPs. Philadelphia has split its last ten at 5-5, a step behind Toronto’s form. The lineup and bullpen strikeout edge are Philadelphia’s real assets here, not its rotation, and those are durable, season-long advantages.
Blue Jays vs Phillies Pick
This is a matchup between two starters having poor seasons, and the honest read has to include both directions of travel: Scherzer has been excellent lately while Nola has slipped below his own bad season line. That’s a real complication for backing Philadelphia. But the Phillies still hold the wider structural edges: a 1.81 FIP gap over the full season, a 31-point OPS advantage, and a bullpen that misses far more bats. That’s enough to trust the deeper body of work over three recent starts. Take Philadelphia.
Phillies.
Pick: Philadelphia Phillies -162
|
Pick
Philadelphia Phillies -162
|
New Player Bonus
50% up to $1000
|